Vic gundotra, a former senior vp of social at google, says that he “might by no means use an android smartphone for pictures!” this announcement become sparked in the comments of a latest fb post of his, which changed into in praise of the iphone 7’s computational pictures (or, portrait mode) prowess. Right here’s why he believes google is behind apple in this front, and why i believe he is incorrect.
Digicam blind test consequences: pixel, s8 and iphone are top, at the same time as lg, htc and sony flop
Google pixel overview: the great android enjoy around
Should or not it’s the stop of an technology? In step with gundotra, the solar is setting on dslr for most people and the destiny is cellular. After taking “beautiful” portrait shots of his kids at a eating place with his mobile cellphone, an iphone 7, he published the pics to facebook and declared “the quit of the dslr for most people has already arrived,” and that he “would by no means buy an android phone once more if i cared about photography.” as a person who ran google’s mobile efforts for years and became an engineering svp, he has numerous information of this problem. But why might an ex-googler consider so strongly in apple’s images era? He explains in a remark:
“right here is the problem: it is android. Android is an open supply (on the whole) working system that has to be impartial to all events. This sounds accurate until you get into the info. Ever marvel why a samsung phone has a harassed and bewildering array of image alternatives? Should i take advantage of the samsung camera? Or the android camera? Samsung gallery or google pics?
It is because whilst samsung innovates with the underlying hardware (like a higher camera) they should convince google to permit that innovation to be surfaced to other applications via the appropriate api. That could take years.
Also the greatest innovation is not even happening at the hardware degree – it’s going on at the computational images degree. (google was crushing this 5 years ago – that they had had “auto remarkable” that used ai techniques to mechanically cast off wrinkles, whiten teeth, upload vignetting, and many others… But recently google has fallen back).
Apple does not have most of these constraints. They innovate inside the underlying hardware, and just sincerely update the software program with their latest improvements (like portrait mode) and ship it.
Backside line: if you clearly care approximately extremely good photography, you personal an iphone. If you do not thoughts being some years in the back of, purchase an android.”
Theory vs exercise
On the face of it, his argument approximately why android phones are supposedly years behind is convincing. However permit’s communicate approximately outcomes. Two android telephones nevertheless fared better typical than the iphone in our maximum recent blind digicam test throughout snap shots in a diffusion of environments. The google pixel, followed intently with the aid of the samsung galaxy s8, honestly produced better photographs than the iphone 7 plus, according to androidpit readers’ votes.
Google pixel iphone 7 plus digicam take a look at consequences
Google pixel on the left (1f, 4b), iphone 7 plus at the right (1a, 4f). / © androidpit
The ongoing dominance of the pixel, which turned into launched six months before the galaxy s8 and just a month after the iphone 7 plus, is due in large part to software innovation in place of hardware. The digicam app of the pixel is full of upgrades – and it’s miles proprietary, no longer freely to be had to google’s competition, not like like the pixel’s digicam sensors or the often open android operating gadget. So, google has each motive to maintain developing its computational pictures innovations at full speed, simply as unconstrained as apple. Google’s opposition, within the case of samsung as a minimum, seems to haven’t any hassle retaining up both, as the galaxy s8 did nearly in addition to the pixel in our take a look at.
Do you believe vic gundotra? Is android genuinely years at the back of within the realm of pictures? Let us recognize inside the feedback.
A hundred twenty five stocks